Insights: Article

Tax Court Case Proves Good Intentions Can Have Bad Results

July 12, 2017

A recent U.S. Tax Court decision illustrates the sometimes limited value of "good intentions."

In Summers, TC Memo 2017-125, a young couple decided to save money and amicably work out their own divorce agreement without obtaining tax or legal advice. As part of their plan, the husband took a distribution from his IRA and gave half of it to his soon to be ex-wife so she could pay some personal debts prior to finalizing the divorce. 

'Additional Tax' on Early Distributions
Generally, distributions from retirement plans, including IRAs, are fully taxable as ordinary income (unless rolled over to another qualified retirement plan or IRA). Distributions that occur before certain dates can also result in a 10 percent additional tax unless a specific exception applies. For example, one of these exceptions can apply when an "early" retirement plan distribution, otherwise subject to the additional tax, is made to a spouse or former spouse under a qualified judgment, decree or order of a state court.

The taxpayer in the Summers case felt he met the "spirit" of this exception. However, he failed to follow requirements set forth in the tax law because: 

  • The distribution from his IRA was made prior to a state court's decree dissolving the marriage
  • The distribution was not paid directly to the former spouse

Consequently, the IRS assessed additional tax equal to 10 percent of the IRA distribution.

IRS Wins
The Tax Court expressed "considerable sympathy" for the taxpayer's position. However, his failure to comply with the statutory requirements for an exception to the 10 percent additional tax compelled the court to agree with the IRS's assessment.

Plan Ahead
This result serves as a reminder of the value of professional advice in advance of entering into financial transactions. With proper planning, it is possible the couple in this case could have achieved an acceptable financial result and reduced significantly the husband's income tax consequences.

Should you want to discuss any proposed personal or business transactions, review their tax consequences and consider planning alternatives, contact your Eide Bailly tax professional. 

Latest Insights

March 15, 2019
An emergency fund may help alleviate the stress associated with a financial crisis.
March 15, 2019
A recent FASB update will significantly affect the accounting for operating leases. Here’s a breakdown of the changes.
March 13, 2019
Properly documenting opioid use in patients is critical to avoiding a denial. Here are seven strategies that should be present in every entry in a patient's health record.
March 13, 2019
Think you know the difference between an email from a friend and an email from a hacker? You may be surprised to find out the answer.
March 12, 2019
When fraud is suspected, analyzing your organization’s data can be difficult. A fraud examiner can help you break down the information, so you can detect and prevent questionable activity.
March 11, 2019
Taxpayers and businesses dealing with first-time tax debt may qualify for relief through the Fresh Start initiative.